- French Revolution and Napoleon Research Paper delves into an order placed on world history questions with specific source requirement information.
This does not, by any means, resolve the Bonaparte question and tie it up in a neat little package. The evidence that Napoleon's name was removed is undeniable. What is not clear is why Napoleon was considered in the first place and, in the eleventh hour before its first performance, why was Beethoven apparently searching for an out? As we consider this question, we should bare three things in mind. One, Beethoven was always impetuous, taking bold actions at a whim and later reversing himself just as easily. Two, Beethoven was known to have withdrawn an intended or promised dedication at the slightest provocation (example; the Kreutzer sonata was originally intended for George Bridgetower but withdrawn over a comment about a woman). And three, less than four years prior to the switching of the dedication, the Austrian Army had been defeated by Napoleon and the peace afforded by the ensuing treaty was dwindling to the point of certain war. It simply would not have been expedient for Beethoven to honor a potential enemy with a dedication.
Napoleon Bonaparte Essay Examples | Kibin
Given the 's title, hero-warrior interpretations are inescapable. Napoleon was the first to carry that sword and now that the Bonaparte connection has been shown to be tenous, other heros have been proposed. With due regard to the esteemed authors of those scenarios, they seem to be on a quest for a legend to fit the symphony. Alfred Einstein commented, "Why are there a dozen or more programmatic interpretations for the -none of which is right or even convincing? " (A. Einstein,